10 Best Male Enhancement Pills, According to a Certified Nutrition Coach

by Joe Costello, CNC | Male Enhancement


Sexual dysfunction is one of the most frustrating issues a man can face in his life. It can cause marriage issues, romance awkwardness, and a life that exists in a general anxiety bubble.

Worse more, many prescription drug remedies for erectile dysfunction tend to come with a barrage of side effects. But delving into the natural male enhancement realm can be just as frustrating if you are unable to separate the chumps from the pumps (yeah, pun intended).

To find the best male enhancement pill on the market, our experts (Nutrition & Wellness Consultants and Pharmacists) have done extensive research and Supplement Facts Panel (SFP) analysis and discovered what we believe are the 10 highest quality male enhancement pills.

Male Enhancement Pill comparison chart (top 10 highest rated)


TSR Tested? (Y/N)

Best for



Male Extra


Libido, erectile function, vitality




Libido, vitality, sexual health


Max Performer


Sex drive, vitality, blood flow


VigRX Plus




5G Male














Sex drive


Libido Max




On Demand




Do male enhancement pills work?

Yes and no. Male enhancement pills work, but only the absolute highest quality ones. You need to be very picky about which male enhancement supplement you choose. Many of them are next to useless as they lack potency or are missing key ingredients.

On the other hand, our top three recommended male enhancement pills have extremely high overall potency levels, clinically proven ingredients, and 100% natural and safe formulas. If you visit the website of any of our top three ranked options, you will see that the manufacturers of the products provide clinical evidence that the supplements work.

This is an extremely key factor when it comes to evaluating male enhancement products. You need to make sure that the manufacturer has conducted clinical studies and the product, proving that it works. This is very rare, and only our top 3 ranked supplements on this list are actually clinically proven according to their manufacturers.

What Are The Best Male Enhancement Pills? Here’s our top 10 supplement picks:

1. Male Extra (best male enhancement pill overall)

Male Extra Male Enhancement Review

Male Extra is far and away the best option when it comes to natural male enhancement. This stuff is top tier, and you will find it is always consistently ranked as a top product by anyone who knows what they’re talking about.

Male Extra sports an exceptionally potent formula with clinically proven ingredients, large dosages, and a synergistic blend. It’s very reasonably priced and manufactured by a very reputable and legitimate supplement company.

It contains over 1,500 milligrams worth of nitric oxide boosters, testosterone boosters, libido enhancers, and more. This formula covers all the bases and leaves no questions unanswered. It’s designed to optimize blood flow, boost sex drive, increase testosterone levels, and maximize erection quality, and we can tell you from personal experience that this supplement truly delivers on those promises. Even if it didn’t deliver, it wouldn’t matter since it has a 100 day money back guarantee.


  • L-Arginine
  • Pomegranate 40% Ellagic Acid
  • Zinc
  • L-Methionine
  • Methyl Sulfonyl Methane

Male Extra Review


2. Viasil (top supplement for sex drive)

Viasil supplement box

Viasil is undoubtedly one of the best male enhancement pills on the market due to its combination of PDE5 inhibitors, testosterone boosting ingredients, and libido enhancers. The formula was very carefully designed to make sure it covers all the aspects of sexual health enhancement, including helping to relieve symptoms of low testosterone.

With 5 very strong clinically proven ingredients at sufficient dosage sizes, you can be pretty confident this stuff is going to help you out in the bedroom. The fast acting formula is meant to help increase libido while also ensuring you are able to achieve the best erection possible. The effect it has on blood flow and PDE5 is ultimately what makes it so efficient.

There’s no question Viasil is high quality, it’s reasonably priced, and the manufacturer has a great reputation in the supplement industry. What’s not to like here? It checks all of our boxes, and we strongly recommend it for enhancing sexual performance. Plus, you have nothing to worry about since it comes with a money back guarantee.


  • Horny Goat Weed
  • Zinc
  • Citrus Sinensus
  • Ginkgo Biloba
  • Tribulus Terrestris

Viasil Review


3. Max Performer (fast acting natural option)

max performer supplement box

Max Performer is a male enhancement supplement that combines four effective ingredients in exceptionally large dosages to produce optimal effects. We love the way the formula is designed. Its advanced nitric oxide boosting profile is what makes it one of the best male enhancement supplements on the market.

Max Performer boasts one of the highest overall potencies in the market place, dosing four of their ingredients at 1,000 milligrams per serving. The formula is completely natural, which is another plus. However, it’s worth noting that the supplements ranked above it are also completely natural.

We love this major up and comer in the male enhancement space, and it has slowly worked its way up our rankings over time as the manufacturer, Silver Blade Brands, continues to improve the formula and deliver on their promises in terms of benefits. This is a great option of you really want to improve your sexual performance.


  • Horny Goat Weed
  • Maca Root
  • Ginseng
  • Cordyceps
  • Zinc
  • Bioperine
  • Selenium
  • Niacin

Max Performer Review


4. VigRX Plus (one of the cheapest options)

VigRX Plus Male Enhancement

VigRX Plus primarily made it onto this list due to the fact that it is a solid cheap option. Its important that you know the formula is significantly weaker and less potent than the supplements ranked above this one. In terms of the formula itself, this product is very average. We only ranked it here because we feel there is some solid value.

There is a big downward jump in quality from our top three recommendations down to VigRX Plus, but this is still a decent supplement with some high quality ingredients, and we know some of readers like to hear about the cheap options.

You only get about 1,000 MG worth of nutrients per serving (lower than average potency, but you get what you pay for). With that said, the nutrients are at least very high quality, and the dosages are pretty significant. We like this male enhancement pill if you’re on a tight budget and need a quick boost in your sex life. Otherwise, we actually would not recommend it.


  • Ginseng
  • Saw palmetto
  • Ginkgo biloba
  • Damiana
  • Tribulus terrestris
  • Muira puama
  • Epimedium leaf
  • Catuba bark
  • Bioperine

VigRX Plus Review


5. 5G Male (decent alternative to prescription drugs)

5G Male Review

5G Male is a very mid tier male enhancement product. The formula is solid, but it’s missing a few key ingredients, and it lacks potency compared to its superior competitors. With that being said, it contains some solid libido boosting ingredients, which gives it a good amount of potential with regard to sex drive.

It is lacking nitric oxide booster ingredients, which is a problem. Nitric oxide boosters serve to open up your blood vessels, thereby enhancing blood flow and allowing you to achieve an erection more easily. Nitric oxide boosters also can help you get harder erections. Without them, there’s only so much this formula can do.

If you aren’t worried about erection quality and are mainly concerned with sex drive, 5G Male could be a decent choice. There are still several better options listed above, but this one should get the job done.


  • Garlic
  • Ginseng
  • Ginkgo Leaves
  • Ginger
  • Green Tea

5G Male Review


6. Zynev (solid safe option)

Zynev Review

Zynev is may not be one of the elite top three supplements on this list, but for a mid-ranking male enhancement supplement, Zynev really isn’t too shabby. It is ripe with a number of solid ingredients, provides a decent amount of nutrients per serving, and has an okay reputation around the web.

While it isn’t the absolute best thing going, it most certainly isn’t the worst. We do not recommend Zynev very strongly as we are not that confident in it. It is missing several key ingredients, and pales in comparison to our top recommendations when it comes to potency.

However, if you’re looking for a low potency, safe option, this isn’t the worst way to go. Supplements that lack potency can be good for beginners and are often not too expensive, so Zynev could be a solid choice for newbies.


  • Tongkat Ali
  • Saw Palmetto
  • Sarsaparilla
  • Horny Goat Weed
  • Boron

Zynev Review


7. Erectzan (popular product for older men)

Erectzan male enhancement supplement bottle

Erectzan earned a spot on this list due to its thoughtful combination of blood flow enhancing nutrients and libido boosting nutrients. It utilizes ingredients like L-Arginine and Ginkgo Biloba to improve blood flow, while utilizing powerful ingredients like Ginseng to help increase sex drive…so why is it at the bottom of this list?

The problem is, at the end of the day, the overall potency is simply too low. Erectzan also uses a proprietary blend, which means some dosage amounts are hidden from the consumer. It contains good ingredients such as the L-Arginine amino acid, but we can’t see the dosage. These unfortunate aspects are ultimately what led to the downfall of Erectzan, but it’s still a solid enough supplement to deserve an honorable mention on this list.

If you’re serious about finding the most effective male enhancement pill, we would recommend avoiding Erectzan. It just doesn’t have what it takes to compete with the true top notch products.


  • L-Arginine
  • Korean Red Ginseng
  • Barrenwort
  • Ginkgo Biloba
  • Oyster Extract
  • Cistanche Bark

Erectzan Review


8. Extenze (conveniently available option)

Extenze Male Enhancement Review

Realistically, Extenze is not a top tier male enhancement pill, but you can find this stuff pretty much everywhere, so we’re giving it points for being a moderately effective convenient option. Make no mistake, the top three supplements on this list blow this one out of the water. Extenze is not even in the same league as those supplements.

With that said, you can’t go to any convenient store or gas station without seeing it, so we figured it’s worth including in the list. As for the formula, the overall potency is extremely low, but there is a lot of ingredients in here. Extenze contains almost 20 total ingredients.

All of the ingredients are hidden in a proprietary blend and probably severely under-dosed, but still, 20 ingredients is pretty impressive. At the end of the day, we don’t necessarily recommend Extenze or see it as being anywhere close to a top five male enhancement product, but it could be worth picking up if you’re in a hurry and see it at a gas station.


  • Yohimbe Extract
  • Tribulus Terrestris
  • Korean Ginseng
  • Velvet Deer Antler
  • Horny Goat Weed
  • Damiana
  • Muira Puama
  • Pumpkin
  • Stinging Nettle
  • Astragalus
  • Licorice
  • L-Arginine
  • Boron

Extenze Review


9. Libido Max (only good for increasing libido)

Libido Max male enhancement

As the name implies, Libido Max is designed to increase your libido, but the problem we have with it is that it doesn’t do much of anything else. Top tier male enhancement pills increase libido, boost nitric oxide, optimize blood flow, block PDE5, etc. The truly top shelf male enhancement products are comprehensive and cover all of the bases, whereas this one just focuses on libido.

While it can’t compete with the top options, if you have low libido and it’s a higher sex drive your after, Libido Max just might be able to help. It lacks potency, but it offers a solid combination of ingredients that have the potential to get you in the mood. One thing is for sure: this supplement is certainly not all it is hyped up to be. It’s average at best.


  • Horny Goat Weed
  • Tribulus Extract
  • L-Arginine
  • Black Tea
  • Beet Powder
  • Citrulline

Libido Max Review


10. On Demand

on demand for men supplement bottle

On Demand has recently become one of the most popular male enhancement supplements. Rumors have spread that it works well, but rumors have also spread that there may be something in it that’s not legal or natural. Due to some of the news that has been coming out about it, we do not feel comfortable recommending it.

However, assuming the formula is natural as the company claims, it looks pretty decent. Even if the formula was confirmed 100% natural, it still would not be anywhere near as good as any of our top three recommendations. Don’t get it twisted, it certainly belongs at the very bottom of this list.

The reputation of the company is not great, and they are under fire as of late. Additionally, the formula was average to begin with, so this really is just an honorable mention. It can barely even be classified as one of the top ten.


  • Horny Goat Weed
  • Acetyl L Carnitine
  • Ginseng Root
  • Ginkgo Biloba
  • Alpha Lipoic Acid
  • Maca Root
  • Longjack Extract
  • Zinc


What’s the most effective male enhancement pill on the market? Our conclusion

The most effective male enhancement pill on the market is undoubtedly Male Extra. We chose Male Extra based on a variety of factors. It has the most diverse ingredient panel, the highest overall potency, large dosages, clinically proven ingredients, and the supplement itself has even been clinically studied as a whole.

Male Extra is the only supplement on this list that checks every single one of our boxes, and it has the most clinical data backing its claims by far. No other supplement comes even close to having as much evidence it works. It also only gets positive reviews from customers, which is another really good sign.

There are other solid options on this list, but at the end of the day, Male Extra is the clear winner. We are primarily confident in the top three ranked options and would strongly recommend choosing one of the top three as opposed to any of the lower ranked products.

Prescription Drugs Vs Natural Male Enhancement Products

Prescription drugs for erectile dysfunction (ED) and natural male enhancement products are distinct approaches to addressing issues related to sexual function, and they differ in terms of their mechanisms, effectiveness, and regulatory status. Here’s an overview of the key differences:

Prescription Drugs for Erectile Dysfunction

  1. Active Ingredients:
    • Prescription drugs for ED, such as sildenafil (Viagra), tadalafil (Cialis), and vardenafil (Levitra), belong to a class of drugs known as phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE5) inhibitors. They work by enhancing the effects of nitric oxide, a natural chemical in the body that relaxes muscles in the penis, leading to increased blood flow and improved erections.
  2. Hormonal Impact:
    • PDE5 inhibitors primarily target the physiological processes involved in achieving and maintaining an erection, rather than directly influencing testosterone production.
  3. Efficacy:
    • PDE5 inhibitors are clinically proven to be highly effective in treating ED. They are usually taken as needed before sexual activity.
  4. Prescription Requirement:
    • These medications are available only with a prescription, and their use should be overseen by a healthcare professional.
  5. Safety and Side Effects:
    • While generally safe, PDE5 inhibitors can have side effects and contraindications. It’s important for individuals to discuss their medical history and any existing medications with a medical professional before using these drugs.

Natural Male Enhancement Products

  1. Ingredients:
    • Natural sexual enhancement products often contain a variety of ingredients, such as herbs, amino acids, vitamins, and minerals. Examples include ginseng, L-arginine, and various herbal extracts. Many of these natural ingredients have been shown in clinical trials to positively effect sexual performance. In my experience, the right combination of these ingredients in high enough dosages is what can really enhance sexual performance.
  2. Mechanisms of Action:
    • These products may claim to work through various mechanisms, such as improving blood flow, boosting libido, or supporting hormonal balance. Some products may include ingredients believed to have aphrodisiac properties, which can potentially lead to better sexual performance and overall improve sexual function processes in the body as a whole.
  3. Testosterone Influence:
    • Some natural male enhancement products may contain ingredients thought to support testosterone production or influence hormonal balance. However, the impact on testosterone levels can vary, and not all products directly affect testosterone levels. In my experience using natural sexual enhancement products, I have found that they were a big help for me in terms of blood flow, premature ejaculation, and the quality of my erections. I have also found testosterone boosters to be very effective.
  4. Regulatory Status:
    • Natural sexual enhancement products are typically marketed as dietary supplements and are subject to less stringent regulations compared to prescription medications. As a result, their safety and efficacy can vary, and some products may make unverified or exaggerated claims.
  5. Efficacy and Individual Response:
    • The efficacy of natural male enhancement products is variable, and individual responses can differ. Scientific evidence supporting the effectiveness of these products is often limited, and claims may be based on traditional uses or anecdotal evidence. I have had great personal results when using male enhancement products in terms of their ability to improve my sexual function and overall performance in bed, but that doesn’t mean these products will work for everyone.

Important Considerations

  • Targeted Areas of Action: Prescription ED medications primarily target the physiological processes involved in achieving and maintaining an erection. Natural male enhancement products may claim to have a broader range of effects, including improved libido, sexual performance, and overall sexual function.
  • Regulatory Oversight: Prescription drugs undergo rigorous testing and regulatory scrutiny to ensure safety and efficacy. Natural male enhancement products are classified as dietary supplements and are subject to fewer regulatory requirements.
  • Medical Supervision: The use of prescription drugs for ED requires a healthcare provider’s oversight, including consideration of potential interactions with other medications. Natural male enhancement products are often self-administered without medical supervision.

Before using any product to address sexual function or testosterone levels, individuals are strongly advised to consult with a medical professional. They can assess individual health needs, discuss potential underlying causes of sexual issues or sexual dysfunction, and provide guidance on appropriate interventions, whether that be prescription drugs or natural products. I am a Nutrition Coach, but I am NOT a doctor, and you should always consult your doctor first.


How long does it take for a male enhancement pill to kick in?

The really high quality male enhancement pills kick in almost right away. They usually kick in within about 30 minutes of taking it, sometimes even less than that. If you are looking for long term effects though, you should consider buying more than one bottle.

What are the side effects of taking male enhancement pills?

If you are taking prescription pills, there’s usually a long list of side effects. However, all of the supplements reviewed on this list are 100% natural. They do not contain problematic ingredients that would cause side effects like prescription ED treatments do. That’s not to say they aren’t capable of causing side effects. It just would theoretically be less likely in my opinion, but you should always consult your doctor with questions like these (remember, I am NOT a doctor)

What are the best over the counter male enhancement pills?

The best over the counter male enhancement pills are Male Extra, Viasil, and Max Performer. These are all 100% natural options that do not require prescriptions and can be purchased by anyone. Just make sure to buy from the correct website in order to get the lowest price, or you may be overcharged.

Are there any FDA approved male enhancement supplements?

No, there are no FDA approved male enhancement supplements that do not require a prescription. Natural male enhancement products are highly unlikely to ever get FDA approval. The FDA is strict when it comes to anything related to sex and/or penis enlargement, and that’s a good thing.


  1. Exploring scientifically proven herbal aphrodisiacs

  2. Pharmacovigilance on sexual enhancing herbal supplements

  3. Efficacy and Safety of Common Ingredients in Aphrodisiacs Used for Erectile Dysfunction: A Review

  4. Effect of fenugreek extract supplement on testosterone levels in male: A meta-analysis of clinical trials
  5. The Effects of 6 Weeks of Tribulus terrestris L. Supplementation on Body Composition, Hormonal Response, Perceived Exertion, and CrossFit® Performance: A Randomized, Single-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Study
  6. The effects of d-aspartic acid supplementation in resistance-trained men over a three month training period: A randomised controlled trial
  7. Correlation between serum zinc and testosterone: A systematic review
Certified Nutrition Coach at JNC Enterprises Inc.

I’m not just a supplement analyst. I’m an extremely qualified one! I am a Certified Nutrition Coach (CNC) and actually received my certification directly from the National Academy of Sports Medicine. I am also a Nutrition & Wellness Consultant, certified by the American Fitness Professionals Association (AFPA).

Hi, I’m Joe Costello CNC

I’m not just a supplement analyst. I’m an extremely qualified one! I am a Certified Nutrition Coach (CNC) and actually received my certification directly from the National Academy of Sports Medicine. I am also a Nutrition & Wellness Consultant, certified by the American Fitness Professionals Association (AFPA).